Jump to content
APC Forum

Whistlemix oxidizer/fuel ratio for benzoate


dangerousamateur

Recommended Posts

I read several variants now, mostly 70/30 and also 76/23.

 

I would expect the more oxidizer rich fuel to be hotter, but how great is the difference?

 

 

I did some experiments with some very small rockets powered by 70/30 and cu oxychloride like it is mentioned in several tutorials.

 

This does not burn fast enough, I want more power and i wonder if 76/23 is worth to try.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm surprised 70-29-1 (?) with cu oxychloride wasn't hot enough in a small rocket. You said very small so was it bottle rocket size? Did it have a core or end burner? How fine is your benzoate? It seems like coarser benzoate still has pretty good power, it just doesn't whistle good.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

so was it bottle rocket size

6mm (inner d.) x 40mm tubes. About the size I dare to press in my vice without proper equipment.

 

Normal spindle length would be 12mm, I used 16. Otherwise just normal whistle rocket specs.

 

How fine is your benzoate?

Pretty fine, free flowing. Like it came from the dealer. Don't have a ballmill. Potassium benzoate.

Same with the perchlorate.

 

There was still a slight smell of acetone in the fuel, but not much. Maybe this slowed it down.

 

 

I'm surprised 70-29-1 (?) with cu oxychloride wasn't hot enough in a small rocket.

They flew quite well, but i want bullet performance & more payload (tested 2-4g). As long as the tubes can keep the pressure - why not?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maybe a bit off topic, but I had a question about benzoate whistle mixes as well. I've heard that potassium benzoate is less hygroscopic than other fuels commonly incoporated with potassium perchlorate to make whistle. Is this correct? I am mainly interested in using whistle as a booster in shells. Does a potassium benzoate whistle mix have less power for this application than one made with, say, sodium salicylate? Any input would be appreciated. Thanks! :)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Potassium benzoate is less hygroscopic than the Sodium benzoate and salicylate, yes.

 

I have heard than Sodium salicylate is the more powerful of the three in rockets, though I've yet to use this fuel myself. This is likely to translate in to the same for booster, however it will not be by all that much, and in my opinion the lower water absorbing properties of Potassium benzoate outweigh this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wish I had a press for rockets. I have potassium perchlorate, potassium benzoate and copper oxychloride. :wub:
Link to comment
Share on other sites

You can check out Danny's whistle data to get an idea. It seems from his data it would seem that the salicylate data isn't entirely consistent, or at least very sensitive to the catalyst used. I don't do many rockets, but it just strikes me as quite variable.

 

http://www.wichitabuggywhip.com/fireworks/rockets/whistletests.html

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...